| Year | Athlete | Award |
| 2023 | Fletcher Hedge | Third Team |
| 2021 | Toby Millward | Third Team |
| 2021 | Oumar Sissoko | Third Team |
| 2021 | AJ Jarvis | Honorable Mention |
| 2021 | Andy Wilkinson | Honorable Mention |
| 2020 | Inaki Aldao | Second Team |
| 2020 | Toby Millward | Second Team |
| 2020 | Andy Wilkinson | Honorable mention |
| 2018 | Inaki Aldao | Honorable mention |
| 2018 | Toby Millward | Honorable mention |
| 2018 | Renato Silva | Honorable mention |
| 2017 | Edgar Guzman | Honorable mention |
| 2016 | Rob Smith | Honorable mention |
| 2015 | Alan Carr | Honorable mention |
| 2014 | Manuel Lira | Honorable mention |
| 2010 | Sebastian Narvaez | Honorable mention |
| 2009 | Mark Heath-Preston | Honorable mention |
| 2008 | Tom Garrick | Honorable mention |
| 2008 | Mark Heath-Preston | Honorable mention |
| 2007 | Jon Pagel | Honorable mention |
| 2006 | Jon Pagel | Honorable mention |
| 2006 | Romain Couture | Honorable mention |
| 2006 | Juan Carciente | Honorable mention |
| 2005 | Romain Couture | Honorable mention |
| 2005 | Juan Carciente | Honorable mention |
| 2005 | Jared Isenhart | Honorable mention |
| 2003 | David Oluyole | Honorable mention |
| 2001 | Jeremy Boldt | Honorable mention |
| 2001 | Josh Hornbaker | Honorable mention |
| 2001 | Aaron Champenoy | Honorable mention |
| 2001 | Justin Galaska | Honorable mention |
| 2000 | Justin Galaska | Honorable mention |
| 1997 | Akeem Braimah | Honorable mention |
| 1996 | Omandi Owallah | Honorable mention |
