Appearances: 10 • Record: 9-10-1 • Opening Round Record: 8-4-1 • Final Site Record: 1-6-0
| 2023 | |
| Northwestern (Iowa) | W, 2-0 |
| Mid-America Christian (Okla.) | D, 3-3 (W, PKs) |
| Indiana Wesleyan | W, 2-0 |
| Milligan (Tenn.) | L, 1-2 |
| 2022 | |
| Mid-America Christian (Okla.) | L, 1-2 (e.t.) |
| 2021 | |
| Olivet Nazarene (Ill.) | W, 2-1 |
| MidAmerica Nazarene (Kan.) | L, 1-2 |
| 2020 | |
| McPherson (Kan.) | W, 2-0 |
| MidAmerica Nazarene (Kan.) | W, 2-1 (2 ot) |
| Columbia (Mo.) | L, 1-3 |
| 2018 | |
| Marymount California | W, 3-0 |
| Madonna (Mich.) | L, 0-1 (ot) |
| 2015 | |
| Science & Arts (Okla.) | W, 1-0 |
| Lindenwood-Belleville (Ill.) | L, 1-2 (ot) |
| 2014 | |
| Hastings (Neb.) | W, 2-0 |
| Vanguard (Calif.) | L, 1-2 (2 ot) |
| 2013 | |
| Grand View (Iowa) | L, 3-4 |
| 2009 | |
| Bethel (Ind.) | W, 2-0 |
| Lindsey Wilson (Ky.) | L, 0-2 |
| 2008 | |
| Bethel (Tenn.) | L, 0-3 |
