Posted: May 07, 2017
Total Appearances: 18 • Consecutive Appearances: 15 • Record: 24-18 (.571) • Finishes – 1st: 0, 2nd: 2, 3rd: 2 • 1st round record: 12-6
| 2017 (#6 seed) - Final 4 | |
| Briar Cliff | W, 80-75 |
| York | W, 78-76 |
| Bethel (Ind.) | W, 77-75 (OT) |
| Cornerstone | L, 69-57 |
| 2016 (unseeded) - 1st Round | |
| Indiana Wesleyan | L, 113-81 |
| 2015 (#7 seed) - 1st Round | |
| Grace (Ind.) | L, 54-50 |
| 2014 (#8 seed) - Sweet 16 | |
| Concordia (Ore.) | W, 81-78 |
| Davenport | L, 67-65 |
| 2013 (unseeded) - Sweet 16 | |
| Rochester (Mich.) | W, 64-50 |
| Cardinal Stritch | L, 81-56 |
| 2012 (#7 seed) - Sweet 16 | |
| Daemen (N.Y.) | W, 58-48 |
| Saint Francis (Ind.) | L, 61-58 |
| 2011 (#4 seed) - Sweet 16 | |
| Ashford | W, 66-45 |
| Saint Francis (Ind.) | L, 76-74 |
| 2010 (#4 seed) - Final 4 | |
| William Jessup | W, 85-67 |
| Cedarville | W, 70-69 |
| Indiana-Southeast | W, 71-65 |
| Walsh | L, 67-66 |
| 2009 (unseeded) - Final 4 - Elite 8 | |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene | W, 84-75 |
| Oregon Tech | W, 78-64 |
| Bethel (Ind.) | L, 82-77 |
| 2008 (#1 seed) - National Runner-up | |
| Saint Jospeh (Vt.) | W, 111-52 |
| Aquinas | W, 65-61 |
| Bethel (Ind.) | W, 73-69 |
| Northwestern (Iowa) | W, 70-67 |
| Oregon Tech | L, 63-56 |
| 2007 - (#1 seed) - Sweet 16 | |
| Fisher (Mass.) | W, 95-84 |
| Northwest (Wash.) | L, 61-56 |
| 2006 (unseeded) - 1st Round | |
| Evangel | L, 82-74 |
| 2005 (#15 seed) - Sweet 16 | |
| Western Baptist (Ore.) | W, 68-65 |
| Northwestern (Iowa) | L, 72-69 |
| 2004 (#2 seed) - National Runner-up | |
| Saint Scholastica | W, 78-55 |
| Siena Heights | W, 78-75 |
| MidAmerica Nazarene | W, 74-50 |
| Sioux Falls | W, 70-62 |
| Oregon Tech | L, 81-72 |
| 2003 (#4 seed) - Elite 8 | |
| California State-Hayward | W, 76-44 |
| Cascade | W, 76-88 |
| Cornerstone | L, 84-75 |
| 2001 (#15 seed) - 1st Round | |
| College of Idaho | L, 62-58 |
| 1999 (unseeded) - 1st Round | |
| Embry-Riddle (Fla.) | L, 97-73 |
| 1998 (unseeded) - 1st Round | |
| Mayville State | L, 99-72 |
