| Year | Athlete | Award |
| 2022 | Ximena Jauregui | Honorable mention |
| 2011 | Meredith Shuman | Honorable mention |
| 2010 | Morgan Anderson | Honorable mention |
| 2010 | Erika Roberts | Honorable mention |
| 2008 | Whitney Ferguson | Honorable mention |
| 2007 | Jessica Wachtler | Honorable mention |
| 2006 | Jessica Wachtler | Honorable mention |
| 2005 | Jessica Wachtler | Honorable mention |
| 2003 | Kristin Munyon | Honorable mention |
| 2002 | Kristin Munyon | Honorable mention |
| 1999 | Jami Shupe | Honorable mention |
| 1998 | Jami Shupe | Third team |