Posted: May 22, 2023
| Year | Head Coach | Record | Pct. | Conference Regular Season |
Pct. | Conference Tournament |
Conference | Postseason |
| 2023 | Michala Cimino | 41-12 | .774 | 26-2 (1st) | .929 | 2nd | NSAA | -- |
| 2022 | Michala Cimino | 42-13 | .764 | 24-2 (1st) | .923 | 2nd | NSAA | -- |
| 2021 | Michala Cimino | 36-20 | .643 | 21-7 (2nd) | .750 | 5th | NSAA | -- |
| *2020 | Michala Cimino | 10-10 | .500 | N/A | N/A | N/A | NSAA | N/A |
| 2019 | Michala Cimino | 44-20 | .688 | 23-5 (2nd) | .821 | 2nd | NSAA | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2018 | Michala Cimino | 32-23 | .582 | 13-11 (4th) | .542 | 5th | NSAA | -- |
| 2017 | Michala Cimino | 50-16 | .758 | 20-6 (1st) | .769 | 2nd | NSAA | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2016 | Michala Cimino | 34-20 | .630 | 19-5 (2nd) | .792 | 3rd | NSAA | -- |
| 2015 | Michala Cimino | 41-14-1 | .741 | 17-3 (1st) | .850 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2014 | Michala Cimino | 36-17 | .679 | 16-4 (2nd) | .800 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2013 | Michala Cimino | 42-11 | .792 | 14-3 (2nd) | .824 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2012 | Michala Cimino | 44-16 | .733 | 13-1 (1st) | .929 | 2nd | MCAC | -- |
| 2011 | Michala Cimino | 32-19 | .627 | 12-0 (1st) | 1.000 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2010 | Michala Cimino | 32-17 | .653 | 10-0 (1st) | 1.000 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2009 | Ed Lehotak | 29-13 | .690 | 12-0 (1st) | 1.000 | 2nd | MCAC | -- |
| 2008 | Ed Lehotak | 29-14 | .674 | 9-3 (2nd) | .750 | 1st | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 2007 | Ed Lehotak | 34-8 | .810 | 13-1 (1st) | .929 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 2006 | Ed Lehotak | 22-28 | .440 | 7-9 (5th) | .438 | DNQ | MCAC | -- |
| 2005 | Ed Lehotak | 39-31 | .557 | 12-4 (3rd) | .750 | 1st | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 2004 | Ed Lehotak | 43-16 | .729 | 14-2 (2nd) | .875 | 4th | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 2003 | Ed Lehotak | 32-16 | .667 | 14-2 (2nd) | .875 | 1st | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 2002 | Ed Lehotak | 40-11 | .784 | 10-2 (1st) | .833 | 1st | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 2001 | Ed Lehotak | 27-28 | .482 | 8-2 (2nd) | .800 | 1st | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 2000 | Ed Lehotak | 56-12 | .823 | 10-2 (1st) | .833 | 2nd | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 1999 | Ed Lehotak | 43-16 | .729 | 8-0 (1st) | 1.000 | 1st | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| 1998 | Ed Lehotak | 46-13 | .780 | 8-2 (2nd) | .800 | 1st | MCAC | NAIA National Tournament |
| 1997 | Ed Lehotak | 31-16 | .660 | 7-1 (1st) | .875 | 2nd | MCAC | Region IV Tournament |
| Totals | -- | 987-450-1 | .687 | 360-79 | .820 | -- | -- | -- |
| * - On Mar. 16, 2020, the NAIA announced the cancellation of all spring sports as a result of the COVID-19 outbreak. | ||||||||